CONCEPT AND CONTENT OF THE RIGHT TO CASSATION APPEAL
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.32844/ibpala-2024-2.15Keywords:
concept, content, the right to cassation appeal, implementation of the right, objective, subjective, formal prerequisitesAbstract
The right to appeal to higher courts with appeals and/or cassation complaints is an important component of the judicial system in Ukraine. According to Art. 129 of the Constitution of Ukraine, one of the main principles of the judicial system is the provision of a cassation appeal of a court decision, except for cases established by law. Thus, the Constitution of Ukraine enshrines the guarantees of review in the cassation procedure of court decisions. Therefore, the purpose of the article is to study the concept of the right to a cassation appeal and its content. It is established that the legislator in Art. 211 of the CASU uses the term «right to cassation appeal», but does not reveal its meaning. Besides, one cannot fail to pay attention to the fact that the science of administrative process has not sufficiently investigated the meaning of the term «right to cassation appeal». It was proven that the right to cassation appeal in administrative proceedings is guaranteed by the state to the parties and other persons participating in the case, as well as to persons who did not participate in the case, if the court decided the issue of their rights, freedoms, interests and obligations a special legal opportunity to appeal the court decision of the court of first instance after its revision in the appeal procedure, as well as the court decision of the court of appeal in whole or in part within the period established for this purpose. It was substantiated that the realization of the right to cassation appeal is connected with the presence of subjective (the presence of a certain circle of subjects who have the right to file a cassation appeal; the presence of the will of the interested subject to exercise the right of cassation appeal), objective (the presence of the subject of review, i.e. the court decision of the court of first instance after their review in the appellate procedure, or court decisions of the court of appeal) and formal prerequisites (observance by the subjects of the appeal of the procedural deadlines for the appeal and the procedural form of the cassation appeal). Non-compliance by the subject of the appeal with any of the above-mentioned prerequisites entails differentiated legal consequences: leaving the application without movement or returning the cassation appeal.
References
Rishennia Konstytutsiinoho Sudu Ukrainy u spravi za konstytutsiinym zvernenniam hromadianyna Suboty Artema Anatoliiovycha shchodo ofitsiinoho tlumachennia polozhen punktu 2 chastyny 1 statti 239 Tsyvilnoho protsesualnoho kodeksu Ukrainy (sprava pro zabezpechennia apeliatsiinoho oskarzhennia ukhval sudu) [The decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine in the case of the constitutional appeal of the citizen Subota Artem Anatoliyovych regarding the official interpretation of the provisions of paragraph 2 of part 1 of Article 239 of the Civil Procedure Code of Ukraine (the case of ensuring an appeal of court decisions)]. Sprava N 1-30/2010. Rishennia № 12-rp/2010 vid 28 kvitnia 2010 r. URL: http://zakon4.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/v012p710-10 (in Ukrainian).
Holubiev, N.Iu., Kharytonova, N.Iu. (red.). (2011). Holubievoi Tsyvilnyi protses Ukrainy [Civil process of Ukraine]: pidruchnyk. K.: Istyna, 536 p. (in Ukrainian).
Shtefan, M.I. (2001).Tsyvilnyi protses [Civil process]: pidruchnyk dlia stud. yuryd. spetsialnostei vyshchykh zakladiv osvity. Vyd. 2-he, pererob. ta dop. K.: Vydavnychyi Dim «In Yure», 696 p. (in Ukrainian).
Andrushko, A.V., Bilousov Yu.V., Stefanchuk R.O., Uhrynovska O.I. ta in. Tsyvilnyi protses [Civil process]: navch. pos. K.: Pretsedent, 2006. 293 р. (in Ukrainian).
Tymoshenko, O.A. Kasatsiine provadzhennia v tsyvilnomu protsesi Ukrainy [Cassation proceedings in the civil process of Ukraine]: dys... k.iu.n.: 12.00.03. / Kyiv, 2012. 229 р. (in Ukrainian).
Matuzov, N.Y. Lychnost. Prava. Demokratyia. Teoretycheskye problemы subъektyvnoho prava [Personality rights Democracy. Theoretical problems of subjective law]. К., 1996. 342 р. (in Ukrainian).
Fursa, S.Ya. (red.). (2009). Tsyvilnyi protses Ukrainy: akademichnyi kurs [Civil process of Ukraine: academic course]: pidruchnyk dlia stud. yuryd. spets. vyshch. navch. zakl. K.: Vydavets Fursa S.Ya.: KNT, 2009. 848 р. (in Ukrainian).
Vasyliev, S.V. (2013). Tsyvilnyi protses Ukrainy [Civil process of Ukraine]: navchalnyi posibnyk. K.: «Tsentr uchbovoi literatury», 344 р. (in Ukrainian).
Chuchkova, N.O. Peredumovy vynyknennia ta umovy realizatsii inozemnymy osobamy prava na zvernennia do sudu [Prerequisites for the occurrence and conditions for the exercise by foreign persons of the right to apply to the court]. URL: http://archive.nbuv.gov.ua/portal/SOC_Gum/Jursci (in Ukrainian).